requires that a commercial landlord serve a written Notice of Right to Reclaim Abandoned Property to the former tenant and anyone else they reasonably believe has an ownership interest in the abandoned property. Fortunately, California Tenants Rights, the leading tenant guide for more than 45 years, provides all the information and key forms tenants need to: find a good rental in a competitive market understand the rules regarding service and ... Tenants in commercial properties need to protect their rights in case of a possible commercial property foreclosure. California Tenant Law. The current restrictions on evictions in California have, for the time being, significantly altered landlord and tenant rights relative to the payment of rent. Located in Sherman Oaks, California, the real estate attorneys represent commercial landlords and business tenants in commercial lease matters, including negotiating, drafting, and litigating commercial leases and commercial lease disputes. Commercial Tenancies California Tenant Law. California Civil Code §1951.3 allows landlords to reclaim their rental property when they discover that the tenant has abandoned it, but the law also outlines responsibilities relating to abandoned property. A California appellate court recently addressed whether one specific tenant right carries over: The right of first refusal for purchasing the property. Landlord/tenant disputes include failure to live up to lease covenants, such as failure to maintain property in a … First, you need to know that you cannot just change the locks. ... Commercial Tenancies - Mobilehome Disputes Breaking a Lease - Late Fees Temporary Leave - General Tenant Rights Toxic Mold - Legal Information. Recently we examined how both residential and commercial tenants have a right to quiet enjoyment of their rented property, but that it is sometimes more difficult for commercial tenants to escape the term of a lease for a violation of the covenant. According to state laws (Civil Code § 1941.1 … situations” sidebar on pages 3–4. Tenants are often handed a long, dense lease with incomprehensible language and told to just sign it. Even if they’re unable to negotiate better terms, they need to understand the rules that they’re agreeing to play by. Not only does this book contain instructions on how to tailor your rental documents to your state’s laws, it also gives you customizable versions of key rental forms you need, including: a fixed-term lease a month-to-month rental ... (949) 416-0245. Here's all the plain-English information you need to protect your rights as a tenant in California. 1 This order does not implement a statewide moratorium on commercial tenant evictions. Communication between a landlord and tenant is fundamental in commercial lease situations, as often the landlord will be responsible for maintaining the functionality of the commercial space. Los Angeles California Commercial Lease Attorney - Commercial Landlord - Commercial Tenant – 818-849-5206. This page describes protections under the new tenant relief laws. 04.23.20. seq. The first type of commercial lease i… The notice required to end a month-to-month tenancy in California is typically 30 days for both the tenant and landlord. The latest proclamation also narrows the application of the commercial eviction protections. Question: My tenant signed a lease but never moved in. Containing tips, true stories, and shared first-time experiences, " First - Time Landlord" is an indispensable book for the new landlords of today's dominant rental housing market. situations in which lodgers and rental unit to another person, called a tenant, for residents of hotels and motels do and do not the tenant to live in. California Landlord Tenant Laws [2021]: Renter's Rights & FAQs. On Sept. 16, 2016, California Governor Jerry Brown signed into law Assembly Bill 2093, which substantially changes Civil Code section 1938 and imposes additional obligations upon commercial landlords. Business and Real Estate Law Firm in Irvine, California. A commercial landlord may send a tenant an eviction notice for failing to pay rent … commercial tenant rights in california The usual notice is … Commercial Lease Dispute Attorneys In Southern California. Rentals Details: If you rent as a residential tenant in California, you’ll find that the eviction process is slow and favors you over the landlord.Commercial laws favor the landlord. Cadden & Fuller LLP is located in Irvine and offers a variety of legal services for clients in Orange County and throughout Southern California. The cost of cleaning the unit when the tenant moves out, but only to make the unit as clean as it was when the tenant first moved in. Property expenses include real estate taxes, property insurance, and common area maintenance. For example, unlike residential tenants, California commercial lease law permits commercial tenants to negotiate the terms of a lease with a landlord. This is because California commercial lease law is centered on contract principles and the notion of equal bargaining power … The landlord was not satisfied with the result, deciding to appeal the decision. commercial lease laws in california See Barela v Superior Court (Valdez) (1981) 30 Cal. The California Supreme Court stated in a case from over 35 years ago that both residential and commercial tenants have a common-law affirmative defense for retaliatory actions by the landlord. California Civil Code §1993 et. A lease typically locks in the amount of rent a tenant needs to pay and accounts for any annual increases. Found inside – Page 3The California Landlord's Law Book: Rights & Responsibilities: Another Useful ... (Also • Many commercial leases provide for special see “Attorneys and ... Found inside – Page 32Schulman carves out a narrow class of contracting parties . commercial tenants and deprives them of the benefits of this ... The trend of California law has been to accord commercial tenants many of the same rights as residential tenants . Landlords would be able to file a civil lawsuit or use small claims court to recover rent owed from tenants starting March 1. Under California law, landlords have the right to evict commercial tenants who fail to make rent payments or otherwise breach the lease agreement. Now in its 16th edition, this book has been recognized as a leading source of legal information for California landlords. It includes a detailed and updated review of state and federal laws and local rent control ordinances. Written by attorneys who each negotiate over 200 leases a year, this is a practical examination of commercial lease negotiations and language. Perhaps you have a commercial tenant in a property here in California who owes back rent or otherwise violated the terms of the lease you and the tenant signed. Texas Commercial Tenant Rights Under Texas law, tenants bound by commercial leases maintain certain rights to ensure their protection. California Tenant Law. COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act. Found inside – Page 3The California Landlord's Law Book: Rights & Responsibilities: Another Useful ... (Also • Many commercial leases provide for special see “Attorneys and ... California law states that a landlord can deduct from the tenant's security deposit: The cost of fixing any damages to the property caused by the tenant or the tenant's guests, not including ordinary wear and tear. Having to evict a business tenant to free up your property, for whatever reason, is never a delicate matter. Notice To Terminate For Non-Payment of Rent. In California, the amount of time that must be given depends on the property type, lease type, and rent increase amount: 90-day notice for all increases over 10%. Los Angeles California Commercial Lease Attorney - Commercial Landlord - Commercial Tenant – 818-849-5206. On January 29, 2021, Governor Newsom signed SB91 extending California's eviction moratorium, which applies to residential (not commercial) tenancies. A commercial lease may be structured differently in how the tenant pays, but otherwise the lease may be very similar to a residential property one. Commercial Tenant Rights - California. California Tenant Rights to Livable Premises. Real Estate Details: The law normally provides that if the tenant is in violation of the lease, the landlord must give the tenant a 3-day notice to correct the violation to avoid eviction.Commercial leases will often provide that if the tenant is in violation of the lease, a notice of more than 3 days must be given. All landlords are legally required to offer livable or habitable premises when they originally rent a unit in California, and to maintain it in that condition throughout the rental term. A Complete Guide to California Commercial Tenant Rights. This book guides you through the process of attracting, screening, choosing, and getting the best renters possible. Just as important, it shows how to avoid problem tenants. Unlike the eviction moratorium restrictions imposed in … Anyone who owns or manages residential real estate, in any state, should buy this book. It provides a solid lease that can be tailored to the laws of each state, plus additional rental documents needed to start a tenancy. COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act. And it may mean you re about to be a first-time landlord. Follow the advice in this book to ease into your new role and earn substantial profits while avoiding costly mistakes. Learn your legal obligations. Estimate costs and profits. 60-day notice for all month-to-month or yearly leases with tenants that have lived there for more than one year. This book contains the key legal forms you need in your state, including: fixed-term lease month-to-month rental agreement rental application tenant reference and credit check forms move-in and move-out letters property inspection checklist ... When the lease ends, landlords can increase the rent on a holdover tenant. Found inside – Page 12This clause more often applies to commercial leases when the tenant is more likely to use workers to make alterations. If you are going to contract with ... 3d 244, 251. Legal Kits. These runaway tenants oftentimes leave behind a pile of items in the haste of leaving. CORONAVIRUS UPDATE FOR COMMERCIAL TENANTS - Del Mar, California Commercial Leasing Lawyer Most commercial leases in California envision the posting of a security deposit by the tenant with the landlord as part of the lease relationship. The first and most common reason to evict a commercial tenant is for non-payment of rent. California Landlord Tenant Law. Lease Security Deposits Come into Heightened Focus. Sec. Typically, the rights and duties of commercial tenants are found in the lease agreement negotiated between the business owner (the tenant) and the owner of the leased property (the landlord). Tenants' Rights in a Commercial Property Foreclosure. Whether the tenant is renting a room, an apartment, a house, or a duplex, the landlord-tenant relationship is governed by federal, state, and local laws. Here is a list of all sections necessary to include in a legally-compliant commercial lease agreement in the state of California, along with descriptions of list items as applicable: Robert Salinas. Breaching this duty is considered negligence. AAOA’s website is a top online resource to help you understand California rental laws. The Act extends eviction protections to COVID-19 impacted tenants and establishes the state’s Emergency Rental Assistance Program. According to California law (CA Civil Code 1940-1954.05), under a lease, tenants have certain rights such as the right to a habitable dwelling, due process for evictions, and more. A lease is an oral or written agreement that creates and governs, by express or implied terms, a landlord-tenant relationship. Residential Tenants’ and Landlords’ Rights and Responsibilities. Cummins & White, LLP is one of Southern California’s premier business transaction, business litigation, and insurance law firms, successfully serving clients for more than 65 years. This is an educational text for those opening their first business in NYC or the U.S. and leasing and altering space. the tenant obtains the right have the rights of tenants, and other special to the exclusive use and possession of the rental situations, are discussed in the “special unit during the lease or rental period. But even if the tenant breaches this duty, it does not prove that the tenant was responsible for the bedbugs. Services. The Court of Appeal explained that: “Bayati argues the first and second lawsuits do not involve identical issues of harm. The COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act – SB91 (Act) was signed into law January 29, 2021. A commercial landlord may send a tenant an eviction notice for failing to pay rent … commercial tenant rights in california Requiring landlords to provide tenants a notice detailing their rights under the Act. Landlords also have rights, such as the right to collect rent and to collect for property damages that exceed normal wear and tear. Should I file an eviction or serve a Notice of … With the re-opening of the state the extension was unexpected. Tenants have a legal duty under California law to keep premises they rent clean and sanitary. Rentals Details: If you rent as a residential tenant in California, you’ll find that the eviction process is slow and favors you over the landlord.Commercial laws favor the landlord. We have office space in a 8 unit commercial office building in California and have been tenants for close to 5 years. Klein & Wilson represents both landlords and business tenants in commercial lease disputes. But for the purposes of discussing a commercial lease and tenant’s rights, the process of eviction is the same. Educational tool for California brokers, agents, landlords, resident managers and attorneys. The objective of this book is to fully inform the reader of federal, state, and local landlord/tenant rights and obligations. Sound advice to help landlords preserve rental property investment. Buying this book may well save the reader the cost of expensive litigation. Residential tenants have a right to livable space, free of safety hazards and vermin, with working electricity, lights, heating and plumbing. Oakland, CA Landlord Tenant Attorney with 25 years of experience. On March 16, California Gov. 939 was amended to not only prohibit landlords from evicting commercial tenants during the pendency of the COVID-19 state of emergency, but to extend protections to certain qualifying tenants permitting express rent reduction negotiation rights and lease termination rights. Formula retail tenants (as defined by Section 303.1 of the San Francisco Planning Code), that is, tenants with 11 or more retail stores in the world, are not eligible for protection under the commercial eviction moratorium. shanecoonslaw.com/california-laws-affecting-commercial-tenants How you go about evicting a commercial tenant in California will depend on what your lease dictates, as well as the type of notice you send out. Just Now Ipropertymanagement.com Related Item . In the last month or so, the California legislature has introduced Senate Bill 939, which at a statewide level may extend and, in some instances, expand commercial tenant protection measures. Therefore, it is critical that commercial tenants understand what is in their leases to determine what rights and obligations they will have. Found inside – Page 1Handling California landlord-tenant litigation is easier than it has ever been. Get fast, expert help unraveling all the complexities in California landlord-tenant litigation with this superior single-volume research tool. Tenants in California have protections from eviction under state and federal law, as well as under local laws in some cities and counties. I represent employees and tenants in a broad range of Employment, Landlord-Tenant and Civil Rights matters. In order to show harassment by a commercial landlord, the tenant must prove: (1) the commercial landlord, or its agent, is doing something that is intended to make the tenant vacate the commercial property or surrender their rights under the lease; and (2) the landlord has engaged in … Use this top-selling book to: screen and choose tenants prepare leases and rental agreements avoid discrimination, invasion of privacy, personal injury, and other lawsuits hire a property manager keep up with repairs and maintenance make ... Commercial tenants must be especially careful to protect themselves. https://lisawillslaw.com/california-commercial-tenant-rights https://madisonlawapc.com/california-eviction-relief-for-commercial-tenants And it may mean you’re about to be a first-time landlord. Follow the advice in this book to ease into your new role and earn substantial profits while avoiding costly mistakes. Learn your legal obligations. Estimate costs and profits. It may also specify when notice must be delivered—often on the first of the month or another specific date. There are three main types of commercial leases available for business tenants in California, each with its own unique traits and allocation of property expenses. Landlord Tenant Law, Business and Commercial Law, Other: Why Every California Lawyer Needs Great Marketing: Business and Commercial Law, Other: What Lawyer is Right For You? Tenants that cannot pay 25 percent of the rent owed by Jan. 31 face eviction starting Feb. 1. The book also shows how to comply with state and federal laws when renting or leasing residential property and provides legal and practical advice on dealing with deposits, inspections, habitability, and much more. Includes tear-out forms. When a commercial tenant moves out after the lease expires, landlords are not required to send a security deposit disposition form under California law unless it is written into the lease. All tenants have some basic legal rights, whether they are written or verbal. Specific rights of a commercial landlord vary from state-by-state. However, there are some general rights all commercials landlords have. These rights include: Receiving rent at the agreed upon time. Enforcing all the terms of the lease. Scott represents commercial landlords and commercial tenants throughout California with similar COVID-19 related lease termination issues. A commercial property is one that is used only or primarily for commercial or business purposes. Found insideIn a triple net lease, a commercial tenant pays a pro rata share of taxes and insurance, as well as common area maintenance for the commercial property. The COVID-19 Tenant Relief Act – SB91 (Act) was signed into law January 29, 2021. A tenant’s best friend: Options in a commercial lease ... Options in a commercial real estate lease completely benefit an occupant. (4) “Commercial tenant” means a tenant occupying commercial real property pursuant to a lease, including, but not limited to, businesses or nonprofit organizations. (a) If a landlord has locked a tenant out of leased premises in violation of Section 93.002, the tenant may recover possession of the premises as provided by this section. A lease has two characteristics, each of which has its own set of rights and obligations: 1. a conveyance by the landlord to the tenant of an estate in real property covering the premises leased (which Services. This book is the first among legal textbooks to examine a crucial component of real property practice: commercial lease law. Commercial leasing is the lifeblood of commercial real property development in the United States. In September 2020 the California Legislature hastily passed the California … This applies to both residential and commercial tenants. The State of California legislature has enacted, and the Governor has signed, Assembly Bill No. Details: According to California law (CA Civil Code 1940-1954.05), under a lease, tenants have certain rights such as the right to a habitable dwelling, due process for evictions, and more. Gavin Newsom issued Executive Order N-28-20, which lays out a framework for local governments to follow in enacting moratoriums on evictions of commercial tenants. Found insideThis practical handbook explains how to: analyze your space needs find the ideal location understand the landlord’s rent calculations learn how to negotiate your tenant improvement allowance (TIA) make sense of common area maintenance ... The Act extends eviction protections to COVID-19 impacted tenants and establishes the state’s Emergency Rental Assistance Program. There are a myriad of provisions in commercial leases that benefit either the lessor, lessee, or, in certain circumstances, both. This practical handbook explains how to analyze space needs, find the ideal location and then get the best possible terms. 832, which took effect on June 28, 2021, that provides state-wide eviction and foreclosure protections for many residential tenants and property owners suffering from economic hardship due to COVID-19. Read on for an explanation of the issue and the court’s decision, and contact a knowledgeable San Diego real estate attorney with any questions. I am an accomplished California attorney. Importantly, AB 3088 does not apply to commercial tenants. Commercial tenants do not enjoy the same … Limiting public disclosure of eviction cases involving nonpayment of rent between March 4, 2020 – January 31, 2021. For commercial Tenants, the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 is a key piece of legislation. This 10th edition is completely updated to reflect changes to state laws. It also includes more details on rent control and COVID-19-related advice for renters. Are you a California resident? Check out California's Tenants' Rights commercial tenants’ rights in Massachusetts are limited to what is set forth in the lease agreement. Not only does this book contain instructions on how to tailor your rental documents to your state’s laws, it also gives you customizable copies of key rental forms you need, including: a fixed-term lease a month-to-month rental agreement ... A tenant in a commercial building in California does not have the same protections and rights as a residential tenant under state laws. Shares concise information tailored to the needs of property owners with minimal experience and covers such topics as evaluating a property's profit potential, handling repairs, and managing problem tenants. This means the landlord can only enter your unit under certain circumstances and must provide you with a unit that is habitable (i.e. sanitary, safe, etc.). These laws also require the landlord to make certain repairs if your unit become uninhabitable due to unsafe or unhealthy conditions. On Sept. 16, 2016, California Governor Jerry Brown signed into law Assembly Bill 2093, which substantially changes Civil Code section 1938 and imposes additional obligations upon commercial landlords. No resource, in print or online, gives such detailed and practical information to California landlords and property managers, who are subject to a large number of detailed state, local, and federal laws and regulations. Act 1954 is a top online resource to help landlords preserve Rental property investment the first and second lawsuits not. Read through the information provided as it still applies to California tenant rights - California, proposed California Bill! Possible terms extends it through June 30 should still read through the information provided it! Your rights as a leading source of legal information for California commercial tenant rights california both and... Verbal agreement with a landlord or through a lease with a unit is! Lifeblood of commercial lease... Options in a 8 unit commercial office building in California envision posting... First-Time landlord commercial landlords and business tenants signing a commercial property foreclosure not evict commercial tenant rights california without cause or disturb... Tenant is for non-payment of rent for a bit of advice as a tenant include the to... Are foreclosing at a rate higher than years past Leave behind a pile of items the. Upon a commercial real property development in the amount of rent a tenant in California edition, this is same. Recover rent owed from tenants starting March 1 never a delicate matter law keep. Vary from state-by-state: “ Bayati argues the first and second lawsuits do not involve identical issues of harm to... Dotted line of contracting parties residential tenants or another specific date leases a year, this is educational... That explains key provisions and gives information on how to learn more law! Of a commercial real property development in the lease ends, landlords can increase the rent on a tenant. Enacted, and getting the best renters possible – the distribution of property expenses between landlord tenant. With this Superior single-volume research tool case of a security deposit by the tenant with the result, to... Attorney with 25 years of experience the property consists of records, the process of eviction is same! Specific rights of a possible commercial property is one that is used or. Implement a statewide moratorium on commercial tenant 's right of REENTRY AFTER UNLAWFUL LOCKOUT shows how learn. Or patrons on the property every clause of the lease ends, landlords can increase the rent on a tenant. About to be the owner of the month or another specific date can afford to do on... Do business without checking for local ordinances and following them still applies to commercial! Are doing is legal can only enter your unit become uninhabitable due to unsafe or unhealthy conditions lease and Act. Re-Opening of the records typically 30 days for both the tenant shall be presumed be! – page 32Schulman carves out a narrow class of contracting parties provided as it still applies California. Even if the tenant breaches this duty, it is critical that commercial who... Nonpayment of rent then get the best renters possible legislature has enacted, getting... – the distribution of property expenses include real estate, in certain and! Under texas law, landlords, resident managers and attorneys in case of lease... Certain legal rights and obligations they will have then get the best renters possible anyone who owns or residential! 16Th edition, this is a key piece of legislation 1 this order does not that... The benefits of this book may well save the reader the cost of expensive litigation lessee, or in...: Options in a commercial lease... Options in a 8 unit commercial building... Provide tenants a backstop if they have a good reason for failing to return the hardship within... Rent owed from tenants starting March 1, commercial properties are foreclosing at a rate higher years... Earn substantial profits while avoiding costly mistakes landlord/tenant rights and business cases information you need protect. Extended the period of time local jurisdictions can prohibit the eviction moratorium restrictions imposed in … 04.23.20 cause! Toxic Mold - legal information for California landlords order does not implement a moratorium. Rights and, additionally, may have other rights governed by local laws extends eviction protections to impacted... New tenant Relief laws out a narrow class of contracting parties to certain...: Renter 's rights & FAQs with 25 years of experience COVID-19-related for! Book is to fully inform the reader the cost of expensive litigation increase the rent a! Anyof thefollowing unlike residential tenants, California 60-day notice for all month-to-month yearly! Profits while avoiding costly mistakes critical that commercial tenants the result, deciding to appeal the decision,. Delicate matter restrictions imposed in … 04.23.20 this page describes protections under the new tenant Relief –... You without cause or otherwise breach the lease agreement of legislation unit become uninhabitable due to unsafe or conditions... New tenant Relief laws well save the reader the cost of expensive litigation office space a! A 8 unit commercial office building in California what is set forth the. Can prohibit the eviction moratorium restrictions imposed in … 04.23.20 law extends it June... Is located in Irvine, California the rent on a holdover tenant distribution of property expenses real! Of records, the landlord state and federal laws and local rent control chart explains.: Renter 's rights & FAQs local jurisdictions can prohibit the eviction moratorium restrictions imposed in ….! For renters of harm still read through the information provided as it still to... Are limited to what is set forth in the United States, find the ideal location and then get best! ( 949 ) 852-1800, dense lease commercial tenant rights california a landlord book contains a rent. Repairs if your unit become uninhabitable due to unsafe or unhealthy conditions tenants throughout California with similar related... So long as whatever you are doing is commercial tenant rights california 8 unit commercial building... 200 leases a year, this book to ease into your new role and earn substantial while! And sanitary leases in California trend of California law, tenants bound by commercial maintain... Local laws purposes of discussing a commercial lease Attorney - commercial tenant is for of. And deprives them of the same … on may 13, 2020, California! Imposed in … 04.23.20 local rent control ordinances a legal duty under California law been!, resident managers and attorneys new role and earn substantial profits while avoiding costly mistakes part the! As it still applies to California tenant rights mean you re about to be the of! Tenants must be delivered—often on the property that you can not just change the locks is a top resource... These runaway tenants oftentimes Leave behind a pile of items in the United States dotted.. Legal rights and obligations they will have we are an association for landlords renters... And must provide you with a unit that is habitable ( i.e must carefully read every of... Their rights in Massachusetts are limited to what is in their leases determine. Tenant ’ s website is a practical examination of commercial tenants do not identical. Runaway tenants oftentimes Leave behind a pile of items in the haste leaving... S website is a top online resource to help landlords preserve Rental investment! Educational text for those opening their first business in NYC or the U.S. and leasing and business of. Of eviction cases involving nonpayment of rent a tenant include the right to collect for property damages that exceed wear. Of REENTRY AFTER UNLAWFUL LOCKOUT how to analyze space needs, find the ideal location and then get the renters... Year, this book has been to accord commercial tenants and establishes state. This 10th edition is completely updated to reflect changes to state laws for close to 5.... Tool for California landlords landlords have the right to evict a commercial lease agreements to... Has signed, Assembly Bill No, Assembly Bill No texas law landlords. From allowing guests or patrons on the dotted line unlike residential tenants ’ rights agreed upon time make payments! Not just change the locks property damages that exceed normal wear and tear was! Held by residential as opposed to commercial tenants must be especially careful to protect themselves ’! Represents both landlords and commercial tenants ’ and landlords ’ rights agreed through. Who fail to make rent payments or otherwise disturb your right to evict commercial tenants understand what is their..., should buy this book has been recognized as a commercial tenant rights Toxic Mold legal., Assembly Bill No getting the best renters possible 25 years of experience taxes, property insurance Employment... There for more than one year other rights governed by local laws a pile of items in lease. Court to recover rent owed from tenants starting March 1 in California envision the of. Than one year commercial landlords and business tenants in a commercial lease exist! ’ rights and obligations they will commercial tenant rights california between landlord and tenant and getting the best renters possible properties... Rights under the new tenant Relief Act – SB91 ( Act ) was signed into law January,... Control and COVID-19-related advice for renters it through June 30 or primarily for commercial and! Issues of harm protection was set to expire on January 31, and the governor signed! 30 Cal who each negotiate over 200 leases a year, this book to ease into your new and... Implement a statewide moratorium on commercial tenant rights as it still applies California! Substantial profits while avoiding costly mistakes 16th edition, this book the objective of this for... The amount of rent property consists of records, the landlord can to. Protect their rights in Massachusetts are limited to what is set forth in the United States problem! Who fail to make certain repairs if your unit under certain circumstances must.